Judgments on Partition Law
Partition Law – After the preliminary survey is done, any further commissions under section 16(2) of the Partition law should be issued to the same surveyor who carried out the original commission under section 16(1) – A partition action cannot have two preliminary plans.
Plaintiffs filed action on 25.05.1992 to partition the land in the second schedule to the plaint and claimed, said land is a portion of the land described in the first schedule to the Plaint. Defendants on the other hand filing their statements of objections, claimed Plaintiffs have wrongfully included their land in to the corpus of the second schedule to the Plaint. Defendants further contended establishing their title to the said corpus and prayed for a dismissal of the action filed by Plaintiffs and/or for a commission to identify the corpus and carve out their land and exclude the same from the corpus.
At the very outset, a commission was issued under section 16 to the licensed surveyor, H.A.G Jayawickrama who returned the commission with a preliminary plan. Thereafter, Plaintiffs being dissatisfied with the aforesaid preliminary plan had made another application to court to issue a commission on another surveyor named Gamini Malwenna which was allowed by court. The Plaintiffs further contended, the licensed surveyor who made the second plan was agreed upon by both parties and cited the case of Sumanasena V Premaratne (CA 1336 & 1337/F – Court of Appeal Minute dated 06.03.2014 – Salam J and Rajapaksha J) in which a preliminary plan made by the commissioner was disregarded with the consent of the parties to the action.
Thereafter, Learned District Judge, accepting the second preliminary plan tendered the decision in favor of Plaintiffs at the end of the trial and granted only compensation for improvements by 11th and 12th Defendants. Defendants thereafter appealed to Civil Appellate High Court and the appeal was allowed and held, Learned District Judge had erred in not identifying the corpus properly, by having gone against the Section 16 of the Partition Law No. 21 of 1977.
The Civil Appellate High Court entered judgement for the Defendants and Plaintiffs then appealed to the Supreme Court.