Judgments on Matrimonial
Gomes Vs Gomes
FACTS
The Plaintiff instituted action against the Defendant in the District Court of Mt. Lavinia praying for a decree of divorce a “vincula matrimonii” on the ground that the Defendant was guilty of constructive malicious desertion. At the time the action is instituted, Plaintiff continued to live at her matrimonial house with the Defendant and children.
The Plaintiff averred in the Plaint that from April 1995 onwards, there were several disagreements between the parties and that the Defendant and his mother harassed the Plaintiff. The Plaintiff claimed that the Defendant frequently abused, ill-treated and hit the Plaintiff and the children and that he often instructed the Plaintiff to leave the matrimonial home.
The Plaintiff referring to an incident on 07.07.2001 alleged that the Defendant without any reasonable or justifiable cause assaulted the Plaintiff in an inhuman and ruthless manner and ordered the Plaintiff to leave the matrimonial home and threatened to pour kerosene and burn her unless she does so. The Plaintiff specifically averred that as a result she was compelled from 07.07.2001 onwards to terminate all marital relations and connections with the Plaintiff and she and the Defendants ceased to cohabit with each other and live entirely separately from each other but under the same roof at the matrimonial home. It was the position of the Plaintiff that the defendant engaged in the aforesaid conduct with the intention of ending the marriage and that the Defendant is guilty of the matrimonial fault of Constructive Malicious Desertion.
The Defendant on the other hand denied the allegations made against him and took up the position that the Plaintiff has made these false allegations in her efforts to obtain a divorce from the Defendant. He further averred that though there were minor disputes between the spouses he bore those difficulties in the interest of the children.
The Learned District Judge who heard the case observed that The [earned Judge observed that, despite the plaintiff’s claims that the alleged incident was a grave one, she and the defendant had gone together to the Police Station on 08th July 2001 and returned together to the matrimonial home and that, the plaintiff has not asked the police to take any action in pursuance of her allegations of threats, assault and an attempt to set her on fire. In the light of these facts, the learned District Judge held that, the plaintiff had not proved the occurrence of the alleged incident on 07th July 2001, which is pleaded in the plaint.
With regard to the plaintiff’s claim that the plaintiff and the defendant had lived entirely separately after 07th July 2001, the learned District Judge held that, the evidence showed that, after that day, the defendant had his meals in the matrimonial home and that these meals were prepared by the plaintiff, the defendant met some of the expenses of the children and continued to contribute towards a part of the domestic expenses and utilities bills of the household and regularly supplied the household with rice and liquid petroleum gas. The learned judge concluded that this evidence showed that a degree of matrimonial relationship between the spouses had continued after 07th July 2001.
The District Judge having held that the Plaintiff failed to establish that the Defendant was guilty of Malicious Desertion dismissed the Plaint. In Appeal the Provincial High Court of Civil Appeal Holden in Mount Lavinia affirmed the Judgement of the District Court and dismissed the Appeal.
The Plaintiff Appealed to the Supreme Court.